Aikido or Judo?


Question:I'm a Taekwondo 1st dan who is looking for another martial art to make myself a more well rounded fighter. My choices are Aikido or Judo. Which would you recommend and why?

I'm a small guy, 1.70m tall, 63kgs.

Answers:

What do you think is the better enviroment for MMA fights, The cage or the ring?

I personally like judo more because the school tend to be more practical. Just the same, it is the school in your area that will make the difference. They can be taught radically different with Aikido tending towards philosophy and helpful opponents to similar with a lot of sparring. Go to the schools in your area, see if they teach what you are looking for.

I do agree that Aikido's circular soft movements would and should be completely different than your TDK which may help you out a bit. Judo is also a soft art too, so keep that in mind. Either way, you will be learning ranges not typically handled in TDK.
Best of look to you in your search.

Should ultimate fighting (ufc) be band?

Take anything and everything you can depending on your situation and needs.


It's all good for the knowledge.

What is the best martial arts to learn?

Definitely go judo, if those are your only considerations. Personally, I love ju jitsu.

Who is veronica domingo?

Aikido, if you want to learn an entirely different concept of motion, and interception or redirection of force.

Judo, if you like doing strong things, and grappling.

Understand that either discipline will force you to learn how to fall (or more correctly, how to land on the ground). You will fall harder with judo, and more gracefully with aikido.

Your choice.

Fighting Techniques?

I'm partial to Judo, but Aikido is good too. BTW, 1.7 m is taller than I am

Should I choose no gi bjj or bjj with gi?

Aikido for graceful movement and help against multiple attackers, judo for strength, grappling and focus on one opponent...

Hwow do I get someone out of their house to beat them up?

Aikido uses redirection of motion. Judo uses strength and leverage. I have taken both but in a real fight I found Aikido more useful and easier to use.

Musashi Miyamoto?

If you have this option I recommend it, take the Filipino Martial Arts (Kali, Escrima, Silat, etc.) It include weapons training and a lot of sreet fighting, or dirty fighting which can come in handy if someon gets outta line in real life.

For all you balck belts in taekwondo?

I'd recommend judo. Aikido is much more stylized and you need to "learn" how to be an "attacker" as well as the defender. Judo is much more practical.

When i roll and someone puts there Gi or stomach over my face I start to breath really hard?

Judo for fitness and similar aggressiveness, Aikido to experience completely different concepts in movement and body control, and to diversify your martial arts.

Can anybody tell me taekwondo training centre or trainer in east delhi?

Both are fine martial arts. I personally am more interested in aikido than judo, and it may be more suited to someone of your size. The best thing to do is visit the schools and talk with the instructors, take a couple of free lessons, and see which one is more interesting for you.

When i asked people about improving in muay thai, they said do squats, what do they mean by squats?

Since you have just begun to learn TKD now that you are a black belt... stick with that style... If you want to learn a little more self defence Hapkido or Aikido would be a good choice. I dont much like Judo. Hapkido would stick with your Korean theme of martial arts. Its the Korean version of Aikido but with a more blunt twist.

How effective is Chin Na?

I also agree with Jerry L, both are good disciplines to study, Judo will help you in ground fighting, but Aikido will give you a third dimension in throwing techniques as well as work with ground fighting techniques (if the instructor is willing to incorporate other disciplines like Judo or even JuJitsu)

The main discipline I study is Tang Soo Do (which is much like Tae Kwon Do) but I also study Hapkido, but My instructor also likes to incorporate the "ground game" techniques of both Judo and JuJitsu as well as the ground fighting and throwing aspects in Hapkido.

Often we will use the Judo aspect since it does not allow striking techniques (which forces us to rely solely on our submission techniques to win), but focuses on pinning or submitting the opponent, whereas our Hapkido allows for it, but we'll also use the more aggressive techniques in JuJitsu as an addition to the Judo.

So basically, if the Aikido Instructor is open to using Judo or JuJitsu techniques as well, you'll be getting double for what you pay, plus as I said earlier, you get that 3rd dimension of throwing an opponent

So Aikido may be the better choice here, especially if the instructor is open to using other aspects of ground game oriented disciplines.

Does anyone know where I might find a "Drunken Fist" instructor around southern california, best around IE

Niether, do jui-jitsu.

Kata Speed?

Since u r Taekwondo, go for Judo... I'm a Martial Art 5 don too..

How can I high kick someone without hurting them really bad/killing them?

Don't choose an art, choose an instructor.

More Questions & Answers...
  • How can I make a ninja mask?
  • How long does it take to learn the basics of parkour / freerunning?
  • UFC MATCH St Pierre Vs Matt Serra Who Won?
  • I'm looking for a kickboxing/Muay Thai club in south east london. I live in Surrey Quays/Canada Water?
  • How hard should i exerise wushu?
  • What is your opinion on exercise after reading this?
  • Exercises to help to achieve being able to do the splits??
  • Does anyone know.?
  • Does anyone else see how big of a hypocrite Tito "Support the Troops" Ortiz is?
  • Is it very unfortunate to fight for a true martial artist?
  • What would you do in this situation?

    This article contents is create by this website user, Sports1234.com doesn't promise its accuracy.
    Copyright 2007-2009 Sports1234.com     Contact us    Terms of Use

    Sports